Why Standard Emergency Fund Advice Says Never Hold It in Crypto
5 min read
Loading...
5 min read
Imagine you kept your emergency fund in Bitcoin. In March 2020, over two days, it would have lost half its value, right as the same crisis that crashed the price was also costing people their jobs. That is not a hypothetical. It is what actually happened, and it is the reason nearly every piece of standard emergency fund advice says: never hold this money in crypto.
An emergency fund only has one job. It has to be there, at roughly the value you expect, exactly when something goes wrong: a job loss, a medical bill, a car that breaks down and needs fixing before you can work again. Crypto can fail at that one job in a way a savings account cannot, and the reason is not just "it's volatile." It is that crypto's worst drops tend to land during the exact kind of broad economic stress that also causes emergencies in the first place.
On 12 March 2020, Bitcoin opened at roughly $7,960. Within two days it had fallen to about $3,860, a decline of around 51%, in what traders now call Black Thursday (CNBC, 13 March 2020). The trigger was the COVID-19 pandemic hitting global markets all at once: a liquidity crunch, forced selling and a wave of leveraged crypto positions getting wiped out in a cascade.
That same crisis was not just a market event. By 9 April 2020, less than a month later, Indonesia's Ministry of Manpower counted 1.2 million formal workers who had already been furloughed or laid off as businesses shut down under COVID-19 restrictions (The Jakarta Post, 9 April 2020). The same shock that halved Bitcoin's price was, at the same time, the reason a lot of people suddenly needed their emergency fund.
This is the part standard advice gets right and generic "crypto is risky" warnings miss. It is not only that Bitcoin can fall 50%. Stocks can fall hard too. The specific problem is correlation: a severe economic shock, a recession, a pandemic, a market-wide credit crunch, tends to hit risk assets like Bitcoin hard at the exact same time it puts jobs and incomes at risk. Your emergency fund is most likely to be needed during a downturn, and a downturn is also when a crypto-held emergency fund is most likely to be worth much less than you think it is.
A regular savings account does not have this problem. Its rupiah balance does not fall because the stock market or crypto market is having a bad week. That stability is not a minor feature, it is the entire reason an emergency fund is kept separate from the rest of a portfolio in the first place.
Say two people each set aside Rp10,000,000 as their emergency fund in early March 2020. One kept it in a bank savings account. The other held it in Bitcoin.
| Value on 11 March 2020 | Value on 13 March 2020 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Savings account | Rp10,000,000 | Rp10,000,000 | 0% |
| Held in Bitcoin | Rp10,000,000 | ~Rp4,900,000 | ~-51% |
The saver could still cover a real emergency in full. The Bitcoin holder, if they needed the money during exactly those two days, could only cover about half of it, right as the same economic shock was putting their income at risk too. The Bitcoin position might recover months or years later. An emergency does not wait months or years.
Crypto can be a reasonable part of a long-term investment portfolio, held for years, sized to what you can afford to see fall by half without needing to touch it. An emergency fund is the opposite kind of money: short horizon, needed on short notice, and only useful if its value holds up during the exact conditions most likely to trigger the need for it.
Keep your emergency fund in cash or a savings account, and keep any crypto position separate, sized and tracked as part of your longer-term investments instead. You can see both sides clearly, cash reserves and invested positions, in one place on your NetWort Dashboard, which is the simplest way to check whether your actual emergency fund is large enough and separate enough from the parts of your portfolio that are allowed to fall by half without warning. Bitcoin's own price history, including the moves described above, is visible on its NetWort Asset Detail page.